Business Case: How Advent International Made a Fortune in Brazilian Education
After eight chapters of theory, Demaria drops a real case study on us. Not a made-up example. An actual deal. Advent International investing in Kroton Educacional SA, a Brazilian education company. This is where all the concepts from the book come alive.
The date is June 24, 2009. Sao Paulo. Advent just announced it is putting R$280 million into one of the biggest listed education companies in Brazil. The stock market reacts. Headlines call it a bold move. And the question on everyone’s mind: can a private equity firm turn a struggling education stock into a market leader?
Brazil’s Education Market Was a Mess (In a Good Way)
First, some context. Brazil’s private education market took off after a 1996 law change that allowed for-profit schools. From 1997 to 2003, the sector grew at nearly 17% per year. That is insane.
But here is the thing. The market was extremely fragmented. Over 2400 schools, but only 58 had more than 10,000 students. The top 20 schools captured just 20% of total enrollments. This is the kind of fragmentation that makes PE investors drool. Where there is fragmentation, there is opportunity for consolidation.
The numbers were wild. Less than 14% of Brazilians aged 18-24 were in higher education, making Brazil one of the worst performers among developed nations. The public system only covered about 12% of the market and rejected nearly 1.8 million students every year. Private schools had to pick up the rest, but many families simply could not afford tuition.
By 2009, education stocks on the Bovespa had actually underperformed the main index by 35%. A price war, thin margins, and intense competition killed returns. Most investors saw a broken sector. PE firms saw a turnaround opportunity.
The Government Programs That Changed Everything
Two programs made the market interesting for investors. ProUni, launched in 2005, exempted schools from federal taxes if they gave scholarships to low-income students. By 2008, over 225,000 grants per year. FIES was a government loan program financing up to 100% of tuition at private schools. Over 500,000 students used it. Many combined both programs.
These programs basically created a government-subsidized pipeline of students flowing into private schools. For a PE investor, this means predictable revenue backed by the state. As close to a sure thing as you get in emerging markets.
Distance Learning Was the Next Big Thing
Everyone was talking about distance learning. Schools could use the same facilities during the day for regular students and at night for distance learners. Double your capacity without doubling your costs.
But in 2009, nobody had cracked it yet. Whoever figured it out first would have a massive advantage.
Meet Kroton: The Company With the Platform
Kroton Educacional was founded on a simple but powerful idea. Build a standardized education platform that can be replicated anywhere. The model came from the K-12 segment, where Kroton ran about 600 schools with 200,000 students under the Pitagoras brand.
The platform worked like this. Standardized curriculum, standardized quality controls, standardized teacher training. Every new campus added to the network required very little customization. This gave Kroton economies of scale that competitors did not have. While other companies grew by buying existing schools and trying to integrate them (expensive, messy), Kroton grew organically by opening new campuses on its proven platform (cheaper, cleaner).
Kroton was listed on the Bovespa since late 2007, with a market cap of about R$502 million as of June 2009. The stock was not doing well, despite solid financials and growing enrollment. Morgan Stanley projected Kroton would hit 137,000 post-secondary students by 2012, growth of over 400%. EBITDA was expected to compound at 57% annually.
The challenge? Could Kroton take its standardized platform beyond K-12 into post-secondary and distance learning? That was the billion-dollar question.
Advent International: Not Your Average PE Firm
Advent was created in Boston in 1984, spinning off from TA Associates. From day one, the firm was built to invest internationally. By 2009, they had 170 professionals across 29 nationalities, investing in over 600 companies in 41 countries.
Their Latin American fund (LAPEF IV, raised in 2007) was $1.3 billion, the largest PE fund ever focused on Latin America. Kroton was their 15th Brazilian investment since 1997. They had done everything from container ports to restaurant chains. They knew how Brazil worked.
Their philosophy: focus on growth and operational improvement, not financial engineering. They brought in operating partners, former C-level executives who would sit on boards and actively help portfolio companies scale. Exactly what Kroton needed.
The Deal Structure
Here is how the deal worked. Advent invested R$280 million for a 50% stake in PAP, the holding company that controlled Kroton with a 55% stake. The price was R$16.2 per share, a tiny 1.3% premium over the previous day’s price but a 19% premium on the 60-day average.
Then PAP would pump R$220 million back into Kroton through a capital increase at R$12.53 per share, about a 22% discount to the previous close. Existing minority shareholders got subscription rights. If they passed, they would be diluted by 36%. In the end, every shareholder participated, bringing the total capital increase to R$387 million.
Advent got three out of nine board seats and chaired the human resources and financial/M&A committees. Notice the M&A part. That signals what was coming: an acquisition spree.
The Competition Was Real
Kroton was not alone. Three other major listed education companies were fighting for the same market.
Anhanguera was the biggest, with 54 campuses and 450 e-learning centers. Lowest prices, targeting young workers from lower-income families. Patria Investments backed them since 2005.
Estacio had 241,000 students across 29 campuses. GP Investments took a 20% controlling stake in 2008. They were focused on centralizing operations and expanding distance learning.
SEB had been around since 1963, building an integrated system from K-12 to post-secondary with strong distance learning.
All publicly listed. All PE-backed. This was a race.
Why This Case Study Matters
Demaria includes this case for a reason. It shows how PE actually works in real life, not the simplified textbook version.
Look at what Advent did. They invested in a listed company, not a typical PE buyout. They went through a holding company structure, not a direct acquisition. They negotiated both a premium and a discount at different levels of the transaction. They gave themselves board control over the strategic committees that mattered. And they brought actual operating expertise, not just capital.
The case also shows the risks. Fragmented market, regulatory uncertainty (the government could take 3 years to approve a new campus), macro exposure to Brazilian unemployment, and the fact that distance learning was still unproven.
For what it is worth, the bet paid off spectacularly. Kroton went on a massive acquisition spree, merged with Anhanguera in 2014, and became the largest private education company in the world. But that is the epilogue. Demaria’s case study focuses on the decision moment, June 2009, when all of that was still just a thesis on a PowerPoint slide.
That is the real lesson here. PE is not about knowing the outcome. It is about making a disciplined bet when the pieces look right and then doing the work to make it happen.
Previous: Chapter 8: The Future of PE