Flash Boys Chapter 1 - The Secret Fiber Optic Cable That Changed Wall Street
Chapter 1 of Flash Boys opens like a heist movie. Two thousand workers are digging across America. They don’t know why. They don’t know what they are building. And they are told to keep their mouths shut.
If someone asks what they’re doing, the answer is: “Just laying fiber.”
That usually ends the conversation.
The Man With the $300 Million Idea
Dan Spivey was a stockbroker from Jackson, Mississippi, who got bored and moved to Chicago to trade options. Like every trader on the Chicago exchanges, he knew there was money to be made from the price difference between futures in Chicago and stocks in New Jersey. The catch was speed. You had to be fast to both markets at once.
By 2008, exchanges were no longer floors full of screaming humans. They were stacks of computers in data centers. And the only thing limiting trading speed was how fast an electronic signal could travel between Chicago and New Jersey.
Here’s the thing. The fastest telecom lines at the time took about 17 milliseconds for a round trip. That’s 17 thousandths of a second. But Spivey did the math. A straight fiber line should do it in about 12 milliseconds. The existing routes were slow because they followed old railroad paths and zigzagged around mountains.
Five milliseconds slower than physics allowed. And that gap was worth billions.
Drawing a Straight Line Through Mountains
Spivey went to Washington, got maps of every existing fiber route from Chicago to New York. They all had the same problem. When they hit Pennsylvania, they started wiggling. The Allegheny Mountains forced every cable to go around.
So Spivey drew his own line. The straightest path allowed by law. Through small country roads, dirt roads, bridges, private parking lots, even cornfields. He cut over a hundred miles off the distance the telecom carriers used.
Then he drove the route. Two days, five in the morning to seven at night. What he saw was tiny towns and tiny roads with cliffs on one side and rock walls on the other. The construction guy riding with him clearly thought Spivey was insane. But when pressed, he couldn’t find a reason why the plan was impossible.
That was all Spivey needed. No one saying it can’t be done.
The Secret Build
Spivey convinced Jim Barksdale, the former CEO of Netscape, to fund the project. About $300 million. They named the company Spread Networks but hid everything behind shell companies with boring names like “Northeastern ITS” and “Job 8.”
The workers dug in small groups, separated from each other. Nobody knew the full route. Nobody knew the purpose. If they saw anyone digging nearby or asking questions, they had to report it immediately. Spivey was paranoid that someone else had the same idea. “When something becomes obvious to you, you immediately think surely someone else is doing this.”
A construction engineer named Steve Williams got pulled into the project through a chain of phone calls that started with “I have an old friend whose cousin is in trouble.” Classic. Williams didn’t even know where the cable was going until months later when they told him, “Hey, this is going all the way to New Jersey.”
The Obsession With Straightness
In Indiana and Ohio, crews laid two to three miles a day. When they hit Pennsylvania’s blue limestone, it dropped to a few hundred feet. Williams kept having the same conversation with local crews. He’d explain they needed to go through a mountain. They’d say, “That’s crazy.” He’d say, “I know, but that’s how we’re doing it.”
And Spivey was all over him about every tiny detour. When the cable had to cross from one side of a road to the other, Spivey would call and say: “Steve, you’re costing me a hundred nanoseconds.” A nanosecond. One billionth of a second. Then he’d ask, “Can you at least cross it diagonally?”
This is the kind of obsession that either makes you rich or puts you in therapy. For Spivey, it was both probably.
Selling Speed to Wall Street
By early 2010, the cable was almost done and still a complete secret. A year of digging and nobody outside the project knew. They hired a consultant named Larry Tabb who estimated that the spread trade between New York and Chicago was worth $20 billion a year, with about 400 firms fighting over it. Spread Networks had room for 200 on their cable.
“We have two hundred shovels for four hundred ditch diggers,” Spivey liked to say.
The price: $300,000 a month. Or $10.6 million for a five-year lease if you paid upfront. With signal amplifiers and setup costs, each firm was looking at about $14 million total.
The Pitch Meetings
They went to Wall Street in stealth mode. CEOs at every meeting. Non-disclosure agreements before anyone could walk in the room. Spivey carried a four-by-eight-foot map and finger-walked executives through the cross-country tunnel.
The first reaction was always disbelief. Then awe. One trader sat stone-faced for fifteen minutes, then jumped out of his chair and shouted, “SHIT, THIS IS COOL!”
But here’s the problem. After the excitement wore off, people got angry. For $300,000 a month, these firms were basically paying for the right to keep doing what they were already doing. If they didn’t pay, someone else would be faster. They had no choice. “Those people hate us,” David Barksdale said after one meeting.
Some traders, as one salesman put it, “would sell their grandmothers for a microsecond.”
The Banks Show Their True Colors
When Spread moved from small trading firms to big banks, things got really interesting. The contract said banks could use the line for their own trading but couldn’t share it with their brokerage customers. Makes sense from Spread’s perspective. Fewer users means more value.
Credit Suisse was outraged. They said, “You’re enabling people to screw their customers.” And they refused to sign. On principle.
Morgan Stanley had a different approach. They were fine with the restriction. They just wanted Spread to change the wording. “Totally about optics,” they said. They wanted “plausible deniability.” Think about that. A major bank wanted to trade faster than its own customers but just didn’t want it to look that way.
Goldman Sachs? “Goldman had no problem signing it.” No drama. No moral struggle. Just signed.
And that tells you a lot about Wall Street in one paragraph.
The Sunbury Crisis
The cable nearly died in Sunbury, Pennsylvania. The line from the west needed to cross the Susquehanna River, which was incredibly wide. The only drill in the world capable of boring under it was in Brazil. Eventually they got permission to run the cable under a bridge instead.
But after the bridge, the road split. Going straight east hit a dead end. Two parking lots blocked the path. One belonged to a wire rope factory. The other to a grocery chain called Weis Markets. Both owners were hostile or suspicious. Coal companies had abused the state for years, and nobody trusted anyone who wanted to dig.
Going around the town would add four microseconds and delay the whole project. The wire rope guy wouldn’t even talk to them. The Weis Markets chairman was at a golf tournament and had already decided to say no. His ice cream plant was too close.
The entire $300 million project sat there, stuck, because of a parking lot.
Then, for reasons nobody fully understood, the wire rope people changed their minds and sold the easement. The next day, Spread sent out its first press release: round-trip travel time from Chicago to New Jersey, 13 milliseconds.
The line was 827 miles long. They’d beaten their goal of 840.
The Question Nobody Answered
Here’s what stayed with me. Even after the cable was built and sold, nobody fully understood what it would actually be used for. The big question, “Why?”, never got a clean answer. Spivey knew traders wanted speed desperately. He didn’t ask why, and they didn’t say.
But the most telling moment comes at the very end. One Wall Street boss heard the price, $10.6 million upfront or $20 million in installments. He went away to think. When he came back, he had one question.
“Can you double the price?”
Not to negotiate down. To keep competitors off the line.
That’s Wall Street. And that’s the world Michael Lewis is about to take apart, chapter by chapter.
Previous: Introduction - Windows on the World