Financial Stability Epilogue: When Truth Collides With Fraud

Book: Financial Stability: Fraud, Confidence and the Wealth of Nations
Authors: Frederick L. Feldkamp and R. Christopher Whalen
ISBN: 978-1-118-93579-8

The epilogue is where Feldkamp and Whalen stop building theory and name the enemy plainly. Every financial crisis is a collision between fraud and truth. Fraud hides leverage through misrepresentation, theft, manipulation, corruption, or monopoly. Truth exposes it. Debt is senior to equity. Exposure of hidden liabilities crushes equity values. That is not a policy choice. It is accounting physics.

The problem was never capital

Ben Bernanke laid this out in Berlin in September 2007 to the world’s monetary policy leaders. The global economy carried $67 trillion of hidden trade imbalances sitting on equity values. Attorneys, auditors, regulators, legislators, executives, and investors all treated a second measure of debt (off-balance sheet liabilities) as ignorable. Now the same people talk about insufficient capital as the cause.

Hindsight is clear. All hidden debt is somebody’s obligation. For the world economy to function, debt must rank above equity. The fix is disclosure, not more capital buffers on top of lies.

For six-plus years, deluders and the deluded stumbled into a debt contraction hole that government had no choice but to fill. Irving Fisher proved the mechanics in 1933. Investors survived only because the financial system must survive or humanity retreats to something worse than the Stone Age while environmental threats close in. Bernanke conducted the recovery. We have known the cure since 1933.

Truth has consequences you cannot refinance away

Acting together, the world can resolve any financial crisis. What we cannot do is erase the consequences of exposed truth. Central banks can provide liquidity and absorb obligations fundable as disclosed debt. They can forgive debt that will never be collected.

Even debt forgiveness does not wipe income tax liability. Exposed hidden debt creates taxable income to the extent it is not repaid. Business fraud exposure cuts liquidity and earnings through repayment and taxation. Public corruption sends officials to jail and sends dictators running.

Bankruptcy can discharge taxes in cases of innocent hardship. No free democracy can run broad tax amnesty for cheats without burdening honest taxpayers. The 2008-2010 crisis tax stimulus allowed long-term deferral of debt forgiveness income. Abuse killed it quickly.

Ukraine, Russia, and the next collision

The 2014 Ukraine crisis showed the old pattern. A corrupt regime collides with economic freedom (represented by the euro). The president flees. Russia protects him because its leaders struggle to embrace freedom fully. Yet even Russia could not ignore markets. Investors fled Russian stocks and bonds after the invasion.

U.S. credit spreads stayed remarkably calm through March, April, and May 2014 while Russian spreads blew out. The risk is what holding Ukraine hostage does to the euro project. The 1979-1981 Iran hostage precedent matters: Carter froze Iranian assets and set resolution rules. Iran complied right after Reagan’s inauguration because face-saving mattered more than theology.

Adam Lebor’s Tower of Basel shows how letting Nazi Germany’s central bank stay in the BIS helped finance aggression. If the BIS and ECB apply measured financial restraints on Russia, history says compliance follows. No nation Russia’s size survives without trade fund flows. Europe controls those flows.

The tax bomb waiting in offshore structures

A bigger 2014 shock hit U.S. markets through litigation. A bankrupt firm sued its tax advisor over offshore structures that deferred taxes on incomplete asset sales. SEC and IRS standards match the book’s appendix true-sale tests. Income tax on those sham transfers was due when the transactions happened, not when reality caught up.

If $67 trillion of international imbalances existed in 2007, how much income got parked in phony off-balance sheet vehicles in tax havens? The authors guess $10 trillion or more in undisclosed tax liability. U.S. equity markets fell in January 2014 when that lawsuit spread.

Collecting without mercy repeats Versailles logic and risks depression. Forgiving taxes shifts burden from cheaters to honest payers. The answer is recognition, deferral, liquidity support for economies absorbing the errors, and moving on. As investors priced in that resolution capacity, spreads narrowed and equities recovered.

That is the theory of financial stability in one sentence: expose truth, manage consequences, keep the system running.

Previous: Financial Stability Ch 24: Why Stable Markets Are Mathematically Unstable

Next: After Financial Stability: What Feldkamp and Whalen Actually Argue