Commercial Real Estate Brokers: Charting a New Course After the Crash

Book: The Commercial Real Estate Tsunami: A Survival Guide for Lenders, Owners, Buyers, and Brokers
Author: Tony Wood (foreword by Matthew Anderson)
ISBN: 978-0-470-63637-4

Chapter 9 is Wood talking to his own tribe: commercial real estate brokers. After 30 years in the business, he has seen bad cycles before. But even he admits this one feels different. Sales and leasing fell off a cliff. The phone still rings, but callers want advice, not transactions. And advice does not always pay the bills.

Wood’s answer is not “smile and dial” or “fake it till you make it.” He brings in Tom Loeswick, a business coach at Shirlaws with 25 years in commercial real estate, to lay out a framework for surviving the drag period and positioning for recovery.

Business is off 70 percent (and that is just the start)

Loeswick opens with a number every broker will recognize: revenue down about 70 percent. But the recession’s impact on commercial real estate was still in early innings when this was written. Vacancies were still rising. Sales were frozen.

He maps recessions into four phases:

1. The Down: Sharp correction, big losses.
2. The Drag: Choppy, flat, no real recovery.
3. The Release: Retest of the lows.
4. The Up: Long climb back.

Brokers in 2009 were somewhere in the Drag, and Wood was living it. Investment sales had stopped. Tenant rep brokers faced fewer clients, lower rents, shorter lease terms. Listing brokers sat on vacant space that would not absorb for years.

Become efficient, then repackage

Loeswick’s first move is brutal and necessary: cut overhead below breakeven so you have cash to invest in new strategies. Many firms trimmed costs but not enough to maneuver.

Then repackage what you sell. Boom-era services do not match recession-era client needs. Winners shift toward:

• Tax appeals and cost segregation
• Expense management
• Lease restructures (blend and extend: lower rate for longer term and landlord security)
• Lease termination and surrender
• Debt and equity restructure or surrender

These are not glamorous commission plays. They are what clients actually need when they are bleeding.

Positioning and volume, not just hustle

Fewer deals means you need more prospects in the pipeline and a clearer reason to pick you over the broker next door. Loeswick warns that when clients say “you are all the same,” they pick on price. Positioning fixes that.

He also pushes volume. One-to-one cold calling ratios get worse in a declining market because clients hesitate. You need broader outreach and more touches to land the few who are ready to act.

Shirlaws breaks revenue generation into products, positioning, distribution, sales, product design, delivery, and client service. Most managers think they have a sales problem. Loeswick says the problem usually sits upstream: wrong product for the market, weak lead sources, prospects who are not pre-qualified or pre-sold.

Build your recovery strategy now (not after the upturn)

This section hit me hardest. Most firms wait too long to plan for recovery, like selling stocks at the bottom and buying back at the top.

Risk tolerance drives the timing. On Loeswick’s 0-10 scale, risk-averse firms (below 5) show up late and lose market share. Firms comfortable with more risk (6-8) invest in strategy during the Drag and catch the first wave cheap.

Designing a real recovery plan takes 9 to 12 months. Do it while you still have breathing room.

The tsunami will reshuffle relationships. Debt and equity sources will change. Long-standing investor and lender contacts will disappear. New ones will emerge. Loan brokers, investment sales brokers, and tenant reps who build the right relationships early set up the next three to five years of business.

Loeswick uses Silicon Valley in the early 1990s as a cautionary tale. About 900 brokers in 1991. Roughly 300 by mid-1994. Two-thirds gone. “Stay alive till ‘95” was the joke. Most could not.

Surviving is only half the job. If you are the number three firm in your market, you do not want to emerge as number five because you hid while competitors repositioned.

Find the opportunity gaps

Markets shrink the way they grow, just in reverse. Loeswick lists six growth levers and asks which gaps open as competitors fail:

• Positioning: What slots open when other firms collapse?
• Distribution: What new prospect channels can you build?
• New products: What services matter to new owners and tenants?
• Leverage: Can you hire key brokers, partner, or acquire a team?
• Bundling: Can you integrate services competitors sell separately?
• Client base management: Are you wasting time on low-profit clients while ignoring the ones who could become referral machines?

Pick one to three focus areas. Not four. Finish three before you start a fourth. Each project needs a vision (why), strategy (what), and implementation plan (how). Brokers who skip the blueprint and jump straight to tactics end up tired, frustrated, and broke. Wood saw plenty of that in 2009.

Summary: cycles are normal, passivity is optional

The chapter closes with a simple choice. Hunker down and hope, or:

1. Learn to navigate the cycle.
2. Figure out which skills matter in each phase.
3. Build those skills before you need them.

Wood and Loeswick are not pretending the downturn is fun. They are saying the brokers who treat this as a repositioning opportunity, not just a survival drill, will own the recovery.

My take

Chapter 9 is the most “business coach” section in the book so far. Some of the Shirlaws framework (Stages, risk profiles, hockey-stick diagrams) reads like a seminar workbook. But underneath the jargon is a truth Wood learned the hard way: problem-solving for panicked clients replaced traditional deal flow, and brokers who could not monetize that shift or pivot their service lines were in trouble.

The 70 percent revenue drop and the Silicon Valley broker count story land because they are specific. The “repackage your services” list is genuinely useful. If you are a broker still pitching trophy leasing assignments in a market where everyone wants a rent cut and a lease blend-and-extend, this chapter is calling you out.

The recovery strategy timing advice is the single most actionable idea here. If you wait until deals are flowing again to figure out your positioning, you are already late.

Previous: Buyers Beware: Due Diligence in a Distressed Market
Next: How One Top Broker Rode the CRE Tsunami