Investment Advice for Every Investor Type - Behavioral Finance Chapter 15

This is it. Chapter 15 of Behavioral Finance and Investor Types by Michael M. Pompian is where everything comes together. All those chapters about biases, personality types, asset classes, and financial planning? They were building up to this. The final chapter answers the obvious question: okay, I know my investor type, now what do I actually do with my portfolio?

The Core Idea: Best Practical Allocation

Pompian introduces the concept of “behaviorally modified asset allocation,” or BMAA. He also calls it the “best practical allocation.” The name tells you everything. It’s not the theoretically perfect portfolio. It’s the best portfolio that you will actually stick with.

Here’s the thing. A mathematically optimal allocation is useless if you panic and sell everything during the next downturn. Pompian cites Daniel Kahneman, the Nobel Prize winner, who said that financial advising should “guide investors to make decisions that serve their best interest.” And sometimes your best interest is a slightly underperforming portfolio that you can actually live with.

Moderate or Adapt?

Before getting into specific advice, Pompian lays out two guidelines for how to handle biases.

Guideline 1: Wealth level matters. If you’re wealthy enough that no realistic market crash will make you destitute, your advisor can afford to adapt to your biases. Let the rich person keep their quirky allocation if it keeps them happy. But if you’re at risk of running out of money, your biases need to be corrected, even if it’s uncomfortable. Destitution is a worse outcome than a suboptimal portfolio.

Guideline 2: The type of bias matters. Cognitive biases come from bad thinking. You can fix bad thinking with education and good data. Emotional biases come from deep feelings. Those are much harder to change. So the approach is: moderate cognitive biases (teach the person), adapt to emotional biases (adjust the portfolio around them).

Put these two guidelines together and you get a simple matrix. A less wealthy person with cognitive biases? Push them toward the rational allocation. A wealthy person with emotional biases? Give them a bigger adjustment to match how they feel. Everything else falls somewhere in between.

Advice for Each Investor Type

Now the good stuff. Pompian walks through each of the four behavioral investor types with a concrete example for each one.

The Preserver

Preservers are driven by emotion and want a conservative portfolio anyway. In the example, a Preserver named Stan is compared to Steve, a non-biased conservative investor. Stan gets an even more conservative allocation than Steve. Why? Because Stan has maybe a 15% tolerance for loss years. Push him past that and he’ll bail on the whole plan.

The advice for Preservers is straightforward. Don’t throw charts and standard deviations at them. They won’t care. Connect the portfolio to what matters to them emotionally: family, security, future generations. Once a Preserver trusts you, they become your best client. They value expertise and objectivity more than anyone else.

The Follower

Followers are passive. They don’t have their own investment ideas and tend to chase whatever their friends are doing or whatever is hot right now. Their biases are cognitive, not emotional. The big problem? They overestimate their own risk tolerance. They say they can handle a 30% drop but they really can’t.

In the example, Amy the Follower gets a more conservative allocation than Bill, a non-biased moderate investor. Amy thinks she can handle more risk than she actually can, so the portfolio gets dialed back.

The approach with Followers is education. Since their biases are cognitive, you can actually fix them with clear explanations and data. Teach them about diversification. Explain why chasing trends fails. But here’s the problem: Followers tend to say yes to everything, including bad ideas that sound good. So the advisor has to be careful about what they suggest, because a Follower will probably agree to it.

The Independent

Independents are the self-directed investors. They do their own research, make their own calls, and sometimes buy things without telling their advisor. They’re contrarian by nature, which can actually work in their favor sometimes. But they also cling to their original thesis even when conditions change. Their biases are cognitive: confirmation bias, availability bias, self-attribution.

Leo the Independent gets a slightly more conservative allocation than Jack, a non-biased growth investor. The risk here is that Leo will go off-script and make side investments that change his overall risk level without realizing it.

The best approach with Independents is regular educational discussions, not finger-wagging about past mistakes. Respect their independence. Show them data. Because their biases are cognitive, education works. But you have to present it in a way that doesn’t feel like you’re telling them what to do.

The Accumulator

Accumulators are the most aggressive type. They’re often entrepreneurs who built their wealth from scratch. They believe they can control outcomes because they’ve controlled outcomes in business. They’re overconfident, sometimes reckless, and they love the thrill of a winning trade.

Bob the Accumulator gets a more conservative allocation than Brandon, a non-biased aggressive growth investor. Bob thinks he can handle a 45% loss year. He probably can’t, especially since his biases are emotional, not cognitive.

Accumulators are the hardest to advise. Pompian says the advisor needs to take control of the relationship. If you let the Accumulator run the show, everyone loses. The key is showing them how their decisions affect their family, their lifestyle, and their legacy. That’s the emotional connection that gets through to them.

The Bottom Line

The whole book builds to a simple conclusion. The best portfolio isn’t the one with the highest expected return. It’s the one you’ll actually stick with through good times and bad. Know your type. Know your biases. Adjust accordingly. That’s the practical payoff of everything Pompian spent 15 chapters explaining.

Previous: Chapter 14 - Financial Planning

Next: Final Thoughts