Atlas Shrugged Part I, Chapter 9: The Sacred and the Profane - Two Very Different Love Stories

Chapter 9 is a study in contrasts. Rand puts two relationships side by side and lets you see the difference between a connection built on real values and one built on lies. And then, in the last act, she introduces the mystery that will drive the rest of the novel.

Rearden’s Morning-After Speech

The chapter opens with Dagny and Rearden the morning after. Sunlight through Venetian blinds, a quiet room, and then Rearden does something genuinely awful: he delivers a speech telling Dagny that what he feels for her is contempt.

He goes on for paragraphs. He says he wanted her “as one wants a whore.” He says he held it as his honor that he would never need anyone, and now he’s broken. He says he’s giving up his self-esteem for her body. He asks her to slap his face.

It’s brutal to read. Not because it’s mean, but because you can see what he’s actually doing. He’s been raised on the idea that physical desire is low, degrading, separate from his “real” self. So he frames their entire connection as a shameful surrender. He can’t just enjoy something. He has to punish himself for wanting it.

And Dagny? She laughs.

Not in anger. In genuine amusement. She sees through the whole thing. She tells him she wanted him from the first moment and she’s proud of it. “If I’m asked to name my proudest attainment, I will say: I have slept with Hank Rearden. I had earned it.”

It’s a response that rejects his entire framework. She refuses to feel ashamed. And you can feel the relief in Rearden even as he can’t admit it to himself yet.

Jim Taggart Meets Cherryl Brooks

Then Rand cuts to the other love story, and the contrast is sharp enough to cut glass.

Jim Taggart is wandering the streets of New York in the rain, miserable despite the fact that the John Galt Line is a success and his stock is soaring. He doesn’t want to go home. He doesn’t want to see anyone. He stumbles into a dime store and a young salesgirl recognizes him from the newspaper.

Cherryl Brooks is nineteen. She came from Buffalo where her family was a mess. She walked out, bought a Taggart train ticket, and came to New York to make something of herself. She is genuine, honest, and completely taken in by the newspaper story that Jim Taggart was the “guiding spirit” behind the John Galt Line.

What follows is one of the most uncomfortable scenes in the book. Jim feeds her his fake humility routine. “Nothing’s important.” “Unhappiness is the hallmark of virtue.” He tells her that Rearden didn’t really invent his Metal, that Dagny is just a “hard, insensitive woman,” that building things isn’t really great.

Cherryl pushes back gently. When Jim says Rearden didn’t invent anything because he used other people’s knowledge, she asks, “The iron ore and all those other things were there all the time. Why didn’t anybody else make that Metal?”

She’s smarter than Jim gives her credit for. But she’s also nineteen, alone in New York, and looking up at someone she thinks is a hero. Jim sees a mirror that reflects back the image he wants. The scene is creepy because he knows it’s a lie. He catches his own reflection, “the tall body distorted by a sloppy, sagging posture,” and feels satisfaction that she can’t see the real him. He feels like he’s pulled something over on her.

He doesn’t even want to sleep with her. He gets no pleasure from the opportunity. He just enjoys having someone who believes in him. And when he sends her home to her miserable rooming house, he feels “as if he had committed an act of virtue.”

The Colorado Boom and Its Enemies

After the Jim and Cherryl section, Rand cuts through a series of shorter scenes showing the aftermath of the John Galt Line’s success.

Rearden and Dagny settle into their affair. He comes to her apartment, they talk business and plans, and there’s a warmth between them that’s undercut by his refusal to acknowledge it as anything but a shameful desire. She wears the Rearden Metal bracelet. They plan a transcontinental track.

But the world outside is shifting. Companies are fleeing to Colorado. Mr. Mowen, a small businessman in Connecticut, watches the Quinn Ball Bearing Company pack up and move west. He complains about everything: about people leaving, about Wyatt producing too much, about not getting enough Rearden Metal. The young worker loading the machines, Owen Kellogg, gives him dry, knowing answers. When Mowen asks what should be done, Kellogg says, “You wouldn’t care to know.”

And the unions are already pushing: slower trains, shorter trains, more workers. Neighboring states want Colorado capped so they don’t fall behind. Orren Boyle wants limits on Rearden Metal production. Wesley Mouch is gaining power.

The Motor

Then comes the discovery that will carry the rest of the book.

Dagny and Rearden take a road trip together. Their vacation turns into visiting abandoned factories and mines, because neither of them can actually rest without purpose. They end up driving through the ruins of Starnesville, Wisconsin, looking for the old Twentieth Century Motor Company.

The town is devastated. People live without money, trading things among themselves. A woman who looks sixty turns out to be thirty-seven. Children stare at their car with the blank eyes of “savages ready to vanish.” A kid throws a rock at their windshield. A man pushing a hand plow works a distant field.

In the gutted factory, Dagny finds something in the ruins of the laboratory. A coil of wire that triggers a memory from her engineering studies. She digs through the junk pile, cutting her hands, and uncovers the broken remnant of a motor unlike anything she’s ever seen. Along with it, she finds a partial manuscript describing the design.

It’s a motor that draws static electricity from the atmosphere and converts it into power. An idea that scientists had given up on generations ago. But someone built a working model. Someone solved the problem.

Rearden reads the manuscript and says, “Good God.”

The implications are staggering. An engine that needs no fuel beyond a few pennies to keep the converter running. Unlimited energy. It would add ten years to the life of every person in the country.

But who made it? And why is it sitting in a junk pile in a dead town?

Dagny vows to find the inventor. Rearden thinks he’s probably dead. “If he were still alive, you would have had the locomotives with the self-generators years ago.”

The chapter ends with Dagny standing at the factory window, looking out at the valley below, where the only lights are the pale smears of tallow candles.

That image stays with you. The greatest motor ever conceived, rotting in a pile of trash, while people below live by candlelight. It’s the gap between what could have been and what is. And it’s the question the rest of the novel will try to answer.

Prev: Previous: The John Galt Line | Next: Next: Part I, Chapter 10 - Wyatt’s Torch