Inside the Distressed Debt Market: Size, Players, and Strategies
Corporate Financial Distress, Restructuring, and Bankruptcy by Edward I. Altman, Edith Hotchkiss, and Wei Wang (Wiley, ISBN 978-1-119-48180-5)
← Previous: Sovereign Default Risk and Z-Metrics | Next: Investing in Distressed Debt Strategies →
Chapter 14 is Altman doing what he does best: defining a market, measuring it, and tracking who plays in it. The distressed debt market has grown from a niche corner for “vulture” investors into a genuine asset class with 30 years of return data.
How distressed debt gets defined
Back in 1990, practitioners tossed around loose definitions like “bonds trading below 80% of par.” Altman tightened this up with two precise categories:
- Distressed: bonds or loans yielding 1,000+ basis points above comparable U.S. government securities
- Defaulted: securities of firms that have actually defaulted and are in Chapter 11 restructuring
This distinction still shapes how the industry tracks these securities today.
Market size: boom and bust cycles
The market’s growth tracks credit cycles almost perfectly.
In 1990, distressed and defaulted debt totaled about $300 billion face value ($200 billion market value). The LBO fallout of 1989-1991 was the main driver. Returns over 40% in 1991 helped birth the professional asset class.
The dot-com bust pushed totals to $940 billion face value by 2002. Then the 2008 financial crisis sent the market to $3.6 trillion face value and over $2 trillion market value. Lehman Brothers alone had $600+ billion in liabilities. There were 49 billion-dollar liability bankruptcies in 2009.
By 2017, during a benign credit cycle, totals had shrunk to $747 billion face value and $414 billion market value. But the authors expect dramatic growth when the next credit crisis hits.
Who invests in distressed debt?
In the early 1990s, about 60 specialized hedge funds managed roughly $100 billion. By 2018, that grew to maybe 200 U.S. funds and 100 international ones, managing $400-500 billion total.
These aren’t just small niche players anymore. Private equity firms, mutual funds, and large institutions all participate. The supply-demand imbalance of the early 1990s and 2002 has narrowed. Pricing is more efficient. Anomalies are harder to find.
Three investment strategies
The chapter breaks distressed investing into three main approaches:
Active control (target: 15-25% annual return)
The “big boys and girls” strategy. Buy enough debt to control the company through bankruptcy, inject equity, restructure, and exit in 2-3 years. Think Wilbur Ross rolling up U.S. steel (LTV, Bethlehem, Weirton) or Eddie Lampert’s Kmart-Sears combination.
This requires at least one-third ownership to block reorganization plans and half to control. It’s basically private equity through the debt side.
Active noncontrol (target: 12-20% annual return)
Stay involved without taking over. Join creditors’ committees, arrange DIP financing, maybe get a board seat after emergence. Hold for 1-2 years. Less capital needed than control strategies.
Passive (target: 10-15% annual return)
Buy discounted debt and bet on recovery. Could be distressed-but-not-defaulted bonds at 50-60 cents on the dollar hoping for a tender offer or turnaround. Or defaulted bonds bought at the price nadir before reorganization lifts values.
Passive investors often trade with 6-month to 1-year horizons. Hedging is common: short the equity while holding distressed debt, or buy credit default swap protection.
Why distressed debt matters as an asset class
The correlation data is striking. During stressed credit cycles (1990/91, 2001/02, 2008/09), correlations between defaulted bonds and the S&P 500 were just 12-23%. Over the full 1987-2018 period, the correlation was only 39%.
That low correlation makes distressed debt attractive for portfolio diversification. The tradeoff: correlations spiked above 70% post-2009 between high-yield bonds and stocks.
Capital structure arbitrage
The chapter also covers capital structure arbitrage: simultaneous positions in different securities of the same issuer to capture pricing anomalies.
As credit quality deteriorates, yield curves invert. Shorter-dated bonds trade at higher yields but higher dollar prices because they have a better chance of getting paid at par before default. Longer bonds trade closer to expected recovery rates.
Traders can set up bullish or bearish positions across seniority levels, maturities, or between debt and equity. Hedge ratios get optimized for expected return subject to maximum loss constraints.
Valuation is everything
Successful distressed investing requires valuation skills spanning both debt and equity, plus legal and fixed income knowledge. It’s not purely a credit play or an equity play. It’s both, with patience and sometimes aggressive activism mixed in.
The next chapter digs into actual returns. Spoiler: the numbers are wild.
← Previous: Sovereign Default Risk and Z-Metrics | Next: Investing in Distressed Debt Strategies →